Krave wellness retreats logo

White Tea vs Green Tea

Cultivation and Processing

Both white and green tea have tremendous health benefits and are derived from the Camellia sinenses tea plant. The crucial way in which teas differentiate from each other is largely attributed to how they are cultivated and processed. White and green tea are both considered to be lightly processed, as opposed to black tea. Another crucial part of processing is how the tea leaves are dried. So for example, either being first sun-dried or dried in the shade. White tea leaves are those that have first been sun-dried while green tea leaves are those that were dried in the shade. For white tea, after they are sun-dried on bamboo sheets, they are then quickly brought indoors to then wither allowing the tea leaves and their white-tipped buds to retain their whitish color. Processing of white tea can be difficult at this stage because cultivators have to control the indoor environment such as temperature and humidity.

Contrast this to green tea, which is dried in the shade and then pan-fried or steamed, causing them to lose some of the whitish color characteristics. Sometimes green tea is pressed into a needle-like shape and dried into a curled shape. Overall, white tea processing is a much gentler process compared to green tea.

Flavor Characteristics

The flavor notes of white tea are often described as fruity flowers or fresh hay. White tea is known for its overall light body. White tea generally has a light gold color. While green tea has a stronger taste profile described as fresh grass, vegetal, and sometimes toasty. Generally, it’ll have a golden-greenish color.

Caffeine

A general rule is that Camellia sinenses tea leaves that have younger buds contain more caffeine. Then you must consider how long your steep tea leaves, as this will affect the caffeine content. The longer you steep tea leaves or the higher the temperature of the water is, the more caffeine content is extracted out of the tea leaves. Other factors like growing conditions, the time of harvesting, and the processing methods are additional factors in the caffeine content of white and green teas. Another general rule is that teas that are harvested in spring and summer times have more caffeine content versus other seasons. There have been a few studies that have tested various teas and found various levels of caffeine content. It led researchers to discover that it is hard to come to a conclusion about general caffeine levels for consumers to expect in teas but they did find that white teas generally have higher caffeine content. But as mentioned above, there are various factors that must be taken into account so at times a person can find that their green tea actually has more caffeine compared to an alternative white tea.

White Tea vs Green Tea

Health Benefits

Both white and green tea have a potent antioxidant called EGCG (epigallocatechin gallate), which is a catechin, a potent polyphenol. EGCG has been well researched and found to have benefits in decreasing the risk of heart disease, skin clarity by improving the skin’s photoprotection from UV ray damage, anti-aging properties by decreasing the breakdown of elastin and collagen, weight loss, lowering LDL (bad) cholesterol, and reducing the risk of various cancers. Both green and white teas have various levels of catechin levels and there are broad ranges for each of these teas. Researchers found that green tea has between 21 to 228 mg/g of total catechin vs white tea has between 12 to 369 mg/g. So regardless of which tea you drink, there is a tremendous amount of antioxidants you are consuming as the differences are relatively small. Specifically, when looking at white teas – there are largely three different types – Silver Needle, White Peony, and Shou Mei (or Long Life Eyebrow). One study found that White Peony has a significantly higher level of EGCG content compared to the others but this difference decreased when steeped at a lower temperature of water. So the argument can be made that taking these factors into account, you can certainly find a white tea that has a greater quantity and concentration of antioxidants. These antioxidants have an impact on decreasing the risk of heart disease by lowering bad cholesterol levels, reducing the risk of certain cancers, and helping with weight loss. Below is an excellent video by Dr. Mike about the many health benefits of green tea so definitely check it out to learn more!

Interested in learning more about teas?

Check out our post about the best teas for digestion and the many health benefits of green tea shots!

Share
Dr. Tyrrell Jenkins

Hi, I'm Dr. TJ

Health Coach + Experienced Physician

Dr. Tyrrell Jenkins, affectionately known as Dr. TJ, has practiced medicine in 4 areas, including outpatient primary care, urgent care, hospital medicine, and the intensive care unit, which are all unique and have given him a significant breath of clinical experience that many physicians do not possess. This has allowed him to assess and manage the continuum of diseases.

frame

1:1 Private Coaching

Private 1:1 coaching program is specifically for those who have struggled and become frustrated with their thyroid dysfunction, irritable bowel syndrome (IBS), or small intestinal bacterial overgrowth (SIBO) condition. This private coaching is for those who have tried restrictive diets and feel that they are going in circles with no improvement. This is for those who are looking to fast track their progress with a personalized approach.

View More Posts

yoga

Best Time to Do Yoga

Best Teas for Digestion

Best Teas for Digestion

Ginger and Turmeric Shots

Ginger and Turmeric Shots